Several months after the 2007 recession began, some economists projected the economy would not recover until 2014. Six years sounded like it was much too long, particularly since the country had just gotten back on its feet from the 4 1/2 years of the 2001 recession and recovery. The most recent announcement by the Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) illustrates how the ongoing lack of primary job creation has caused the recovery to be so long and painful.
On June 1, the monthly BLS press release stated, “Nonfarm payroll employment changed little in May (+69,000). Employment increased in health care, transportation and warehousing, and wholesale trade but declined in construction. Employment was little changed in most other major industries.”
If Colorado is growing at the same pace as the U.S., the BLS will announce, later in the month, that the state will post a gain of about 1,200 jobs in April. (Colorado nonfarm employment is about 1.72% of the U.S. total.)
When this release hit the newswires, the equity markets tanked. In addition to the weak job gains, investors were worried about Greece’s debt problems, U.S. debt, the recession in parts of Europe, the slowdown in the Chinese and Indian economies, and much more. While these are clearly legitimate concerns, the decline in employment should not have come as a surprise. Past economic forecasts prepared by The Conference Board foretold of the pending dip.
TCB has forecasted that 2012 output will be at its lowest level in Q2. It stands to reason that subpar output will be accompanied by weak employment growth for April, May, and June. On a positive note, output (consumption, housing starts, and capital spending) is projected to improve slightly in Q3 and Q4. The average rate of output growth for the year will be about 2.2%. This suggests that employment will improve along with the increased output. Next year, 2013, will only be slightly better. The good news is that the trends are in a positive direction.
The recovery will continue to be painfully slow for a number of reasons:
• According to the TCB, output in advanced economies is growing at a rate of 1.3% – worse than the U.S. The emerging economies have stronger growth, 5.6%. Colorado companies that export agricultural and manufactured goods may have greater opportunities in emerging countries.
• The number of federal workers continues to decline.
• The intent of the stimulus funding was to create private sector jobs. Those jobs were supposed to kick in when stimulus funding was reduced. Unfortunately, too few private sector jobs have been created and funding is being diminished. This makes the stimulus efforts appear to be ineffective.
• Although revenues have improved for many state and local governments, their budgets remain tight. In Colorado, state employment is flat and local governments have fewer jobs than one year ago.
• Overall inflation has been kept in check; however, energy prices, and the prices of other commodities, are noticeably higher than when the recession started.
• The construction and housing markets have not rebounded as quickly as anticipated. Colorado construction employment is at the same level as it was in the mid-1990s, although it is finally trending upward.
• Companies have been able to meet their sales targets by investing in capital rather than labor. Productivity gains have allowed companies to maintain a competitive position without adding workers. At some point in the next 18-24 months this will change and companies may be forced to add workers.
The latest job numbers are disappointing, but not surprising. There will be slight improvement in the second half of the year, with continued volatility in 2013.
Continued patience is required. At the earliest, 2014 will be the year when stronger growth can be expected.
©Copyright 2011 by CBER.