Colorado Economic Forecasts Point to Growth in 2015

It is the forecast season and three Colorado economic forecasts are on the streets.

First, the Governor’s Office of State Budgeting and Planning and the Colorado Legislative Council released their2015 Colorado economic forecasts.

Their forecasts are used for policy and budgetary purposes and at times tend to err on the conservative side. (That comment is intended to serve as a reference point, and is not meant as a criticism). The March forecast is often a more accurate reflection of what will happen during the year.

The good news is that both groups are realistically optimistic about the state’s outlook.

OSPB projects U.S. Real GDP growth of 2.7% with state job growth of 68,300. CLC is slightly more optimistic. They project U.S. Real GDP growth of 3.1% and state job growth of 73,600.

The quarterly reports produced by OSPB and CLC are recommended reading for anyone interested in the state economy. They discuss the economy for all regions of the state, key industries, and factors that impact the budget for the state government.

Finally, Richard Wobbekind recently unveiled the CU Leeds School Colorado economic forecast earlier in the month.  As usual it was a rewrite of the past four years. He expects the U.S. to see significantly stronger U.S. output growth. At the same time he focuses on Colorado being one of the leading states for job growth, yet he states that Colorado will add jobs at a decreasing rate in 2015 after modest growth in 2014. CU is projecting Real GDP growth of 3.1% and state job growth of 61,300 in 2015. Those numbers just don’t make sense.

Between now and next year, Wobbekind and the CU gang should read the paper “Macroeconomic forecasts and microeconomic forecasters”. Author Owen Lamont raises the question, “Does an experienced research team, with a wealth of knowledge, produce a more accurate forecast or does the added knowledge result in an “arrogance” which may reduce the accuracy of the forecast? The state would benefit from CU producing a Colorado economic forecast based on academic rigor rather than self-promotion.

The good news is that this part of the forecast season has passed and all projections point to continued modest growth in 2015. Bring on the new year!

 

Leeds Economic Forecast Points to Slower Growth in Year Ahead – AGAIN

On December 8th Professor Richard Wobbekind and the Leeds School of Business (SOB) released the 49th annual economic forecast for Colorado. Unfortunately, the fundamentals of the 2014 outlook were as questionable as the 2012 and 2013 forecasts.

For three consecutive years (2012 to 2014) the SOB has projected fewer jobs would be added in the coming year, even though Real GDP was predicted to increase significantly in two of those three years.

A summary of the SOB forecasts from 2012 to 2014 are provided in the table below.

 

Leeds School of Business Forecast – US Real GDP and Colorado Employment

Year

Change in Real GDP

Change in State Employment

 

2012

In 2012 Real GDP will show a significant increase in the rate of growth for 2011

Fewer jobs will be added in the coming year

 

2013

In 2013 Real GDP will growth at about the same rate as 2012, a slight decrease is possible

Fewer jobs will be added in the coming year

 

2014

In 2014 Real GDP will increase at a rate almost double the 2013 rate

Fewer jobs will be added in the coming year

 

Source:  SOB BEOF publications

 

The actual data for 2012 and preliminary data for 2013 are provided in the table below.

 

Performance of the Economy – US Real GDP and Colorado Employment

Year

Change in Real GDP

Change in State Employment

 

2012

The rate of growth of 2012 was significantly greater than the rate of growth for 2011

More jobs were added in 2012 than 2011

 

2013

The 2013 preliminary rate of growth was significantly lower than the rate of growth for 2012.

More jobs were added in 2013 than 2012

 

2014

To be determined

To be determined

 

Source: BLS, BEA, CBER

 

A historical look at the recoveries from the last three recessions is instructive.

After the 1991 recession, Colorado added jobs at an increasing rate for three years (1992 to 1994). This recovery was exceptionally strong. Job growth in 1994 was second highest in state history.

  •  Following the 2001 recession, Colorado “added” jobs at an increasing rate for four years (2003 to 2006). That rate of recovery for that period was anemic, but improving. Continued job growth at an increasing rate was cut short by the 2007 recession.
  •  After the 2007 recession, Colorado has “added” jobs at an increasing rate for four years (2010 to current). The rate of recovery has been so-so. In other words, there is a strong likelihood that job growth will continue at an increasing rate in 2014.

The saying “Every blind squirrel finds an acorn now and then” can be applied to the 2012-2014 SOB forecasts. If they continue to predict the state will add fewer jobs next year than this year, at some point they will be correct. Will 2014 finally be the year they are right?

We can only hope the SOB is wrong again!

 

©Copyright 2011 by CBER.